
The Twenty Two
Best for travelers who want a small, social hotel with private members’ spaces and a Flatiron/Union Square base.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Twenty Two is a small, members-club–style five-star hotel in the Flatiron/Union Square area; this guide is for travelers who want boutique design, a private-club atmosphere, and easy downtown access. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a legendary Upper East Side luxury hotel; read on if you value classic Manhattan formality, a full-service spa, and Central Park proximity.
Updated · about 3.0 miles (4.8 km) apart

Best for travelers who want a small, social hotel with private members’ spaces and a Flatiron/Union Square base.

Best for travelers looking for established Upper East Side luxury, suite choices, and on-site full-service spa facilities.
When The Twenty Two wins: choose The Twenty Two if you want a compact, design-forward hotel with a members-club social scene, easy access to Union Square and downtown neighborhoods, and a boutique, discreet stay.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle if you prefer a larger, historic Upper East Side institution with a full-service spa, more room-and-suite variety, and iconic public venues like Bemelman's Bar.
Bottom line: both hotels prioritize discretion and refined service; pick The Twenty Two for a newer, intimate private-club experience and The Carlyle for old-Manhattan luxury and larger property amenities.
| Category | The Twenty Two | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, members-club–centric boutique hotel | Traditional, formal Upper East Side luxury hotel |
| Location | Flatiron / Union Square, steps from Union Square Park | Upper East Side, near Central Park and the Met |
| Size (rooms) | 76–78 keys, including ~17–19 suites | 188 guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / access | Hotel minimum check-in age 18; club areas restricted to 21+ after hours | All-ages hotel (not adults-only); standard luxury-hotel access rules |
| Pools | No pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Café Zaffri (modern Levantine) + members’ dining and lounges | Two restaurants, Bemelman's Bar and a bar/lounge (supplier listing) |
| Spa & wellness | No traditional spa; 24-hour Technogym fitness centre and on-request treatments | Full-service spa and health club (supplier listing) |
| Known for | Members’ Living Room, private-club rules and vinyl nights | Classic Manhattan pedigree, Rosewood affiliation, Bemelman's Bar |
| Travel links | Very close to major subway hub (Union Square) and downtown neighborhoods | Walkable to Central Park and major museums (Met, Guggenheim) |
| Accessibility & service | 24-hour butler service, 12 ADA-accessible rooms, concierge | 24-hour front desk, multilingual staff, concierge, wheelchair-accessible features |
The Twenty Two sits at 16 E 16th St in the landmarked Margaret Louisa Home a minute from Union Square Park.
Choose The Twenty Two for downtown energy and immediate access to Union Square transit and neighborhood life.
The Carlyle is on the Upper East Side (35 E 76th St), a short walk to Central Park and the Met.
Choose The Carlyle to stay near Central Park and Museum Mile in an established, quieter neighborhood.
The Twenty Two offers 76–78 keys with a mix of Classic and suite options and club privileges for guests.
The Twenty Two is for travelers who want a boutique, highly serviced room and on-site club access.
The Carlyle lists 188 guestrooms spanning standard rooms to multi-bedroom suites.
The Carlyle is the better pick if you need more room-type choices or larger suites.
The Twenty Two centers dining around Café Zaffri and members’ dining spaces.
Pick The Twenty Two if you want contemporary, chef-led Levantine dining plus members’ room service and club meals.
The Carlyle has multiple dining outlets and a famous bar scene.
Pick The Carlyle if you want classic hotel restaurants and a storied hotel bar experience.
The Twenty Two’s signature is its private members’ spaces and curated social programming.
If a hotel-club social scene interests you, The Twenty Two is designed around that offer.
The Carlyle’s signature features are its classic hotel public rooms and a full-service spa.
The Carlyle suits guests who want on-site spa treatments and formal public rooms rather than a private-club vibe.
The Twenty Two offers a 24-hour Technogym fitness centre and curated wellness/treatment collaborations.
Choose The Twenty Two for round-the-clock gym access and a private-club nightlife program.
The Carlyle provides a formal hotel nightlife and on-site spa/health club.
Choose The Carlyle for an on-site spa and conventional hotel evening venues.

The Twenty Two — it’s built around members’ spaces, vinyl nights and a club-first guest experience.

The Carlyle — a full-service spa, larger property and long-standing Upper East Side reputation.

The Twenty Two — steps from Union Square, the Greenmarket and a major subway interchange.

The Carlyle — many room types and a wider selection of suites, including Central Park–facing options.
The Carlyle is closer to Central Park and Museum Mile (Met); The Twenty Two is better for downtown museums and Union Square-area culture.
Yes — overnight guests are designated 'Temporary Patrons' and have access to select members’ spaces (The Living Room) until 6pm; full club access is reserved for members.
Yes — the supplier listing specifies a full-service spa and health club.
No — neither property is adults-only. The Twenty Two does enforce 21+ access rules in some members’ areas after 5pm.
Explore how The Twenty Two stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·