
The Twenty Two
Best for members‑club energy, intimate scale, and a Flatiron/Union Square location.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Twenty Two is a small, members-club–style five-star hotel in a landmarked Edwardian brownstone near Union Square; read this if you want intimate, clubby luxury and easy access to downtown Manhattan. The St. Regis New York is a historic Fifth Avenue 5-star with formal butler service and old‑New‑York prestige; read this if you prefer grand, traditional luxury and a midtown address.
Updated · about 3.1 km apart

Best for members‑club energy, intimate scale, and a Flatiron/Union Square location.

Best for old‑New‑York formality, full butler service, and a central Fifth Avenue address.
When The Twenty Two wins: choose The Twenty Two if you want a smaller, clubby hotel experience with strong local personality, a single notable restaurant (Café Zaffri), 24-hour butler service in a landmarked Edwardian setting close to Union Square and downtown neighborhoods.
When The St. Regis New York wins: pick the St. Regis for a larger, traditional luxury hotel with a famous Fifth Avenue address, extensive meeting and event facilities, a long history of butler service, and a more formal, midtown location near Rockefeller Center and MoMA.
Bottom line: both deliver polished Manhattan luxury; The Twenty Two is for travelers who prefer boutique, members‑club style energy and a downtown base, while The St. Regis suits those wanting formal, historic Fifth Avenue luxury and larger hotel services.
| Category | The Twenty Two | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Members‑club energy, intimate and contemporary in a landmarked brownstone | Formal, old‑New‑York ultra‑luxury with traditional service rituals |
| Location | 16 E 16th St — Union Square / Flatiron (downtown Manhattan) | Two East 55th St — Fifth Avenue / Midtown (near Rockefeller Center & MoMA) |
| Size | 76–78 rooms, including 17–19 suites and a rooftop penthouse | 238 guestrooms |
| Check-in / Check-out | Check-in after 3:00 PM; check-out by 12:00 noon | Check-in begins at 4:00 PM; check-out by 12:00 PM |
| Pools | No swimming pool on site | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Café Zaffri (modern Levantine) plus members' dining spaces and a hotel bar/lounge | Two restaurants and 1 bar/lounge; room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa / wellness | No traditional spa; 24-hour Technogym fitness centre and on-request high‑tech treatments | Not published |
| Known for | Private members' spaces (The Living Room), clubby nights, boutique scale | Butler service, Fifth Avenue address, longstanding luxury reputation |
| Accessibility | 12 ADA‑accessible rooms; stair‑free path to entrance and elevators | Wheelchair‑accessible registration desk and accessible paths; accessible meeting spaces |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome at the hotel; club areas restrict access to 21+ after 5pm | All ages welcome (property does not list adults‑only policy) |
The Twenty Two sits at 16 E 16th St, a minute's walk from Union Square Park and close to Flatiron, Greenwich Village and downtown subway connections.
Choose The Twenty Two if you want a downtown base and quick access to Union Square and Flatiron neighborhoods.
The St. Regis New York is on Two East 55th St, steps from Fifth Avenue, St. Patrick's Cathedral, MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Choose the St. Regis for a formal Fifth Avenue location near midtown museums and shopping.
The Twenty Two is a small hotel with about 76–78 keys and 17–19 suites in an Edwardian house.
Expect intimate, design‑forward rooms with butler service in a converted brownstone footprint.
The St. Regis offers 238 air‑conditioned guestrooms with a long tradition of butler service.
Expect a broader range of room sizes—including large suites—and classic, formal guestroom styling with butler service available.
The Twenty Two centers its food offering on Café Zaffri, an all‑day modern Levantine restaurant that’s open to the public.
Choose The Twenty Two for a single strong restaurant identity and club dining options rather than multiple large hotel restaurants.
The St. Regis lists two restaurants and one bar/lounge, plus limited‑hours room service.
Choose the St. Regis if you want more extensive in‑house dining and a more traditional hotel dining program.
The Twenty Two does not have a swimming pool but centers guest experience on members' club spaces and rooftop areas.
The hotel's signature is its private club and rooftop terraces rather than a pool or large amenity complex.
The St. Regis emphasizes service rituals tied to its Fifth Avenue location and event space rather than a single signature rooftop club.
The St. Regis' signature is formal service and event capability anchored to a Fifth Avenue address.
The Twenty Two offers a 24‑hour Technogym fitness centre and hosts club nights in its members' spaces.
Good choice if you want 24‑hour gym access plus clubby nightlife within the hotel footprint.
The St. Regis lists a 24‑hour fitness facility and salon among its guest services.
The St. Regis offers round‑the‑clock fitness and on‑site grooming but published spa details are not provided here.

The Twenty Two — choose it for small scale, members' spaces and a Union Square/Flatiron neighborhood base.

The St. Regis New York — choose it for formal service, history and a central Midtown address.

The St. Regis — more on‑site restaurants and a larger food & beverage operation for varied in‑house choices.

The Twenty Two — the smaller room count, club spaces and rooftop penthouse favor intimacy and personality.
The Twenty Two — it’s a minute from Union Square and within easy walking distance of Flatiron, Greenwich Village and SoHo.
Both properties offer butler service for many room types; The St. Regis has a long‑standing tradition of butler service and it’s explicitly listed for many room types in the supplier listing.
No. Neither hotel is adults‑only. The Twenty Two does restrict access to some club areas to guests 21+ after 5pm, but the hotel itself accepts guests from age 18 up.
The Twenty Two has no swimming pool and no traditional full‑service spa. For the St. Regis, pool and published spa details are not provided in the supplier listing used here.
Explore how The Twenty Two stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·