
The Twenty Two
Best for travelers who want a small, design-forward hotel with private-members‑club access and modern Levantine dining on-site.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Twenty Two is an intimate five-star hotel and private members’ club in a landmarked Edwardian building near Union Square; read this if you want a boutique, club-connected Manhattan stay. The New York EDITION is a larger, five-star Flatiron lifestyle hotel with a polished restaurant and bar program; read this if you want a stylish downtown luxury base with full hotel services.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for travelers who want a small, design-forward hotel with private-members‑club access and modern Levantine dining on-site.

Best for travelers who prefer a full-service luxury hotel in the Flatiron/Madison Square Park area with on-site restaurant and meeting facilities.
When The Twenty Two wins: choose The Twenty Two if you want a small, characterful hotel tied to a private members’ club, prefer Café Zaffri’s Levantine-led menu, and value a more intimate, club-style experience in a landmarked brownstone.
When The New York EDITION wins: pick The New York EDITION if you want a larger full-service luxury hotel with more meeting space, multiple bars/lounges, an established restaurant (The Clocktower) and a bigger staff operation for business or events.
Bottom line: both suit design-conscious downtown travelers; The Twenty Two is the boutique, club-driven choice for a more private, intimate stay, while The New York EDITION is the safer full-service luxury pick in the Flatiron neighborhood.
| Category | The Twenty Two | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, boutique, club-linked in a landmarked Edwardian house | Stylish full-service lifestyle luxury hotel in Flatiron |
| Location | 16 E 16th St — a minute from Union Square Park | 5 Madison Avenue — steps from Madison Square Park and Flatiron Building |
| Size (rooms) | 76–78 rooms (including ~17–19 suites) | 271 rooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages can stay; minimum check-in age 18; members’ spaces restrict under-21 after 5pm | All ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | No swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Café Zaffri — modern Levantine all-day dining; members’ Dining Room/Living Room upstairs | The Clocktower restaurant; 2 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service |
| Spa / wellness | No traditional spa; 24-hour Technogym fitness centre and high-tech treatment collaborations | Spa services on site and fitness facilities |
| Known for | Private‑club spaces and intimate, historic setting | Flatiron lifestyle hotel with meeting rooms and polished dining |
| Meeting & events | No dedicated conference halls published; private hire options (Louisa’s, Cafe Zaffri) | 2100 sq ft conference space and 5 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility | 12 ADA-accessible rooms; stair-free path and elevators | Wheelchair-accessible paths, accessible rooms and services published |
The Twenty Two sits on East 16th Street a minute from Union Square, offering immediate access to the Flatiron/Union Square neighborhood.
Best if you want immediate Union Square proximity and easy subway connections.
The New York EDITION is located at 5 Madison Avenue, steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building.
Best if you want a centralized Flatiron address with easy access to Madison Square Park and local sights.
The Twenty Two is an intimate hotel in a converted landmarked home with a small set of room types and suite options.
Rooms are boutique-sized and styled for a private‑house feel rather than a big hotel footprint.
The New York EDITION offers a much larger room inventory with many standard, deluxe, loft and suite configurations.
Choose EDITION for a wider range of room sizes and traditional luxury‑hotel amenities.
The Twenty Two’s headline outlet is Café Zaffri, an all-day modern Levantine restaurant open to the public.
Great if you want a distinctive Levantine menu and club-style dining spaces.
The New York EDITION has The Clocktower restaurant, 2 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.
Better if you want multiple on-site outlets and a traditional hotel F&B program.
The Twenty Two does not have a swimming pool and focuses on intimate club spaces and dining.
Not a pool hotel — the appeal is the club and dining experience.
The New York EDITION’s public listing highlights restaurants, bars and meeting space; pool information is not published in the supplied listing.
Pool presence is not published in the supplied listing; the hotel leans on dining, bars and meeting spaces.
The Twenty Two mixes a 24-hour Technogym fitness centre with members’ nightlife programming in private club spaces.
Good for travelers who want gym access plus curated club nights rather than a big spa complex.
The New York EDITION offers on-site spa services, fitness facilities and hotel bars for evening social life.
Better if you want a full-service wellness offering plus hotel bars and easier evening logistics.

The Twenty Two — private members’ spaces, small room count and Café Zaffri’s Levantine menu.

The New York EDITION — more rooms, meeting rooms and a larger restaurant/bar operation.

The Twenty Two — Café Zaffri offers focused Levantine cuisine led by a known culinary team.

The New York EDITION — established lifestyle brand in the Madison Square Park/Flatiron area.
The Twenty Two — booking a room grants temporary access to select members’ spaces (Living Room) though full club access is restricted to members and age rules apply after certain hours.
The New York EDITION — its supplier listing specifies The Clocktower plus two bars/lounges and 24-hour room service; The Twenty Two focuses on Café Zaffri and members’ dining rooms.
The Twenty Two does not have a swimming pool. The New York EDITION’s supplied listing does not publish pool information.
The New York EDITION — it lists about 2,100 sq ft of conference space and five meeting rooms; The Twenty Two offers private hire options but no dedicated conference halls in the published materials.
Explore how The Twenty Two stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·