
The Twenty Two
Best for travelers who want a small, design-led hotel with private members' spaces and a lively Flatiron/Union Square neighborhood base.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Twenty Two is a club-inflected 5-star Flatiron newcomer housed in a landmarked Edwardian mansion; read this if you want a small, design-forward hotel with private members’ spaces and a central Union Square location. The Peninsula New York is a grand, long-established Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with a full-service spa, indoor pool and multiple bars — read this if you want classic Midtown Fifth Avenue luxury with comprehensive facilities.
Updated · about 2.8 km apart

Best for travelers who want a small, design-led hotel with private members' spaces and a lively Flatiron/Union Square neighborhood base.

Best for travelers who want traditional Fifth Avenue luxury, an on-site full-service spa and an indoor pool in Midtown Manhattan.
When The Twenty Two wins: choose The Twenty Two if you prefer a smaller, club-inflected hotel with a strong design identity, closer access to Union Square and a more intimate, member‑club atmosphere.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula if you want a larger, established Fifth Avenue hotel with a full-service spa, an indoor pool, multiple bars/restaurants and easy access to Midtown attractions like MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Bottom line: both are high-end Manhattan options but they serve different needs — The Twenty Two for boutique, club-style stays and The Peninsula for classical Fifth Avenue luxury with fuller on-site facilities.
| Category | The Twenty Two | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, club-forward boutique with historic Edwardian architecture and private members' spaces. | Beaux Arts Fifth Avenue grande dame with traditional luxury hotel services and facilities. |
| Location | Flatiron / Union Square, a minute's walk from Union Square Park and nearby subway connections. | Midtown Manhattan on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, steps from MoMA and Fifth Avenue shopping. |
| Size (rooms) | 76–78 rooms (including 17–19 suites). | 219 guestrooms. |
| Opened | Opened late 2024 / early 2025 (sources vary). | Not published |
| Pools | No swimming pool on-site. | 1 indoor pool (published). |
| Restaurants & bars | Café Zaffri (modern Levantine) + members' dining spaces and a hotel bar/lounge; Café Zaffri open to public. | Clement Restaurant (American) plus 3 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service. |
| Spa & wellness | No traditional hotel spa; offers high-tech spa-treatment collaborations and a 24-hour Technogym fitness centre with personal training. | Full-service spa offering massages, body treatments and facials; 24-hour fitness facilities and steam/sauna. |
| Known for | Access to private members' club spaces (The Living Room) for overnight guests and a strong nightlife/club element. | Classic Fifth Avenue address, full-service spa and established reputation among international luxury travelers. |
| Family & age policy | All-ages hotel with club areas restricted to 21+ after late afternoon; minimum check-in age 18. | Family-friendly property (supplier listing notes children amenities and policies). |
| Parking & transfers | Self-parking at nearby facility and valet on request (published rates and rules). | Secured valet parking available (surcharge); limo/town car service available. |
The Twenty Two sits at 16 E 16th Street in the Flatiron/Union Square area, steps from the park and the busy 14th St–Union Square subway interchange.
Choose The Twenty Two for a more downtown, neighborhood feel with quick subway links.
The Peninsula New York is on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, in the heart of Midtown shopping and cultural attractions.
Choose The Peninsula for the traditional Midtown Fifth Avenue location close to major museums and shopping.
The Twenty Two offers about 76–78 keys including 17–19 suites and a rooftop penthouse in a converted Edwardian mansion.
Choose The Twenty Two if you want boutique-scale rooms with detailed in-room amenities and butler service.
The Peninsula New York has 219 guestrooms across a range of room and suite categories, reflecting a larger, full-service hotel inventory.
Choose The Peninsula for a wider selection of room sizes and suite categories in a full-service hotel.
The Twenty Two anchors its food offering around Café Zaffri, a modern Levantine restaurant open to the public plus members’ dining on upper floors.
Choose The Twenty Two for a focused, chef-led restaurant with private club dining options.
The Peninsula offers a full-restaurant program (Clement Restaurant) and three bars/lounges plus 24-hour room service.
Choose The Peninsula if you want multiple on-site dining and bar options in Midtown.
The Twenty Two does not have a swimming pool; its signature amenities are the private club spaces, rooftop penthouse and intimate social venues.
If a pool is important, The Twenty Two is not the right choice; its draw is club spaces and boutique social venues.
The Peninsula includes an indoor pool and a full-service spa as part of its on-site recreation and wellness offering.
Choose The Peninsula if on-site pool and a traditional spa program are priorities.
The Twenty Two emphasizes fitness and club culture over a conventional hotel spa.
Pick The Twenty Two for active guests who also want a clubby social scene rather than a large spa.
The Peninsula features a full-service spa plus multiple bars and lounges suited to quieter evenings or hotel-based entertainment.
Pick The Peninsula for comprehensive wellness facilities and a quieter, more classical hotel nightlife.

The Twenty Two — small guest count, private members' spaces and a strong Flatiron neighborhood identity.

The Peninsula New York — published full-service spa and an indoor pool.

The Peninsula New York — steps from MoMA and Fifth Avenue retailers.

The Twenty Two — immediate access to Union Square, local markets and downtown neighborhoods.
The Peninsula New York — it has a published indoor pool. The Twenty Two does not have a swimming pool.
Yes — booking a room designates you a Temporary Patron with access to select members' spaces (e.g., the Living Room) during your stay, but full club/bar/nightclub access is restricted and subject to members’ rules and age limits.
At both hotels cooked-to-order breakfast is available but is noted as a surcharge rather than universally complimentary.
The Peninsula New York — it sits on Fifth Avenue near MoMA, Rockefeller Center and high-end shopping; The Twenty Two is better for exploring downtown neighborhoods around Union Square.
Explore how The Twenty Two stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·